Thursday, April 12, 2007

slum

The problem of slum is not really in architectural or urban boundary. Even though we know the way, architect or urban planner couldn’t solve the problem because it is from social conflicts. Like article ‘seventeen reasons why the squatter problem can’t be solved’, the way of exit from slum seems so hard in current system of capitalism and economic development. To pursue the strongest and most innovate culture, society ignore loser as squatter and they lose their place to leave in a city. However, they don’t have anywhere to leave, and then they start making their own area as ghetto in a city.

All of these problems as ‘habitat debate’ mentioned originated from negligence of central government. The government didn’t hear squatter’s voice and they just made and follow its policy. However, to make habitat program effective squatter around the world must band together and to overcome this situation, political policy and their demand of participating is essential (habitat debate, 12)

Also ‘housing as a verb rather than a noun’ is so notable phrase. Just saying home or housing is not sufficient. To make comfortable home, the policy needs to lead squatter to build up their area through self-particiation. For the usual normal urban people housing became shop, factory, and rental income. However, for the people who remain in slum, they don’t have anything to live.

I am not sure how architect or urban planner could approach this problem. In this case, I have usually so pessimistic view to the role of architect. We could say some opinion, but all the decision usually comes from politics. And usually politics could pretend to solve this problem but not usually get into it because they never been in slum culture.

slumming

Slums

It seemed that many of these articles when speaking of slums also referenced words like misconception and myth. It’s interesting to note that some of these misconceptions could have been derived from the evolution of the word “slum” itself. Mike Davis in Planet of Slums defines slums by citing mid nineteenth century sources with words and phrases like “racket”, “criminal trade”, “room with low goings-on occurred”, and “an area of dirty back streets, especially when inhabited by a squalid and criminal population” (pg. 22). He defines the word with a more classical definition of “overcrowding, poor or informal housing, inadequate access to safe water or sanitation, and insecurity of tenure”. What is important to note is that the previous definition had a negative connotation of crime and implied that the people living there were prevalent to social disorder.

Janice Perlam addresses this in Six Misconceptions. She point that squatters are traditionally stigmatized and accused of “social breakdown, crime and prostitution, and maladaptive rural behaviors” and “seen as parasites on the economy” but in reality they “have the aspirations of the bourgeoisie, the perseverance of pioneers, and the values of patriots. She follows up by saying that “What they do not have is an opportunity to fulfill their aspirations”.

The global community and nations in response to such a statement have attempted to give squatters such an opportunity. But again due to misconceptions of slums those attempts have failed to give viable solutions. Shlomo Angel and Stan Benjamin have noted this by describing what they call “technological transfer”. They define it as “the largely unsuccessful attempt to take housing solutions from developed societies and modify them for application in the developing world”. They continue to say “It has the great advantage of fitting well into elite middle-class aspirations. But it fails on three important counts; lack of realism…a complete misunderstanding of people’s needs and poor use of available resources” (pg. 20).

In terms of solving the issues of slums many of the articles were getting to the point of eradicating these misconceptions by actually studying the conditions of the slums and their realities. One article went so far as to define the typology of slums.

While reading these articles I couldn’t help but think back to when Alejandor Aravena came to speak last semester. He discussed a low income housing project that he worked on. He described that the process of the project involved speaking to the community to understand their needs. It was interesting to note that the project did not “look complete” with it cinderblock construction and unfinished walls. But when referencing back to Angel and Benjamin’s article they talk about this “aesthetic desire to produced finished projects”. For the people of the slums, cinderblock meant security and permanence and the ability for them to add on and invest in their homes.

sha_slum

These set of articles made me realize the wide variety of ways this topic is approached, because it affects so many. Angel Benjamin's article almost argues for the slum typology, approaching it as a series of myths or social preconceptions that have led to the miscasting of the slum as "bad" or "inefficient". The statement about families having "no stake" in the large housing projects and how they are "often hostile to them" was a nice encapsulation of the failure of the Corb sort of city. ( I actually got a sense of the article tying back to a more crass article I read sometime last week, Nussbaum's "Are Designers the Enemy of Design?", especially when I was reading reasons 5 and 6, Completeness and Professionalism. It seemed to tie me back to what I've been thinking about all semester, and now I can describe it: is myspace a slum of the internet? Are we as designers squeamish of the visual atrocities while we forget the new ownership that arises from Nussbaum's "democratic design"? )

The other articles all provide differing perspectives and perceptions on the inhabitants of the slum. Planet of Slums inhabits an almost completely statistical approach. Mike Davis's voice is almost absent, and only surfaces in a few locations "but I think most urban newcomers'..." and when he compares the population of slum-dwellers with the population of the world in 1844. I wish there was a mediating article between the Planet of Slums sort of barrage of numbers with the Colors Magazine personality -- a New Yorker "The Apartment" for slums, using impossible numbers and making them real, or at least a little easier to grasp. The same sort of anonymity persists in the UN Habitat article, consistently referring to inhabitants of slums as a vague "they", never referring to people in quantities less than 300.

In that sense the Janice Perlman article is a relief, a softer look at some of the reasons Angel Benjamin proposes, almost as a way to do what Angel Benjamin proposes -- shifting our perception of slums. She, like Benjamin, consistently uses "our" and "we" to include (or implicate) the reader in this discovery of the misconceptions of slums. It is sad, though, that the only article that really sets aside "they" in favor of people is the Colors Magazine article.

http://www.businessweek.com/innovate/NussbaumOnDesign/archives/2007/03/are_designers_t.html

Slum

Architecture 209X, Spring 2007

Words and Cities: The rhetoric and meaning of statistically improbable phrases

Nicholas De Monchaux

Qing Wang

Slum

Does slum count as architecture? If so, does the architecture training help us to design it? The slum has been built without drawings, diagrams, models. It has been built with the available materials around its location. The structure has been lifted up without calculation. It seems all we learn in architecture school doesn’t help to do this? The way that slum has been built raises the question about architecture as a shelter. Slum is nothing but a shelter. If architecture is considered as a shelter, the architect’s task becomes to build a place to protect people from nature. To protect people from nature is not only an architectural problem. Technologically, there is no difficulty to build shelter. Without architects, people in slum do good jobs always. The difficulty architects face when they try to solve this residing problem is that it is merely such a complicated problem associated with social, economical, political and legal problems. It is a social problem more than an architectural problem, even eventually it will materialized as an architectural form. Architects are just one tiny role in this system. Mostly, every architect’s attempt fails in history. High-rise building is one of them. After World War II, Berlin needs be rebuilt over the debris. Architects find new materials and techniques to build buildings faster to accommodate more people who just lost their homes and families in the war. As the city grows, the land value rises as well. Architects solved this problem by stacking floors higher to use space vertically. However, the recent studies shows that the tower needs much high maintenance and construction cost than low-rise and mid-rise. Architects found a new building type, but didn’t solve the problem. Meanwhile, it causes some other problems like rush hours traffic jam, disconnection between people, and pollution. In this design “game”, architects always play with themselves. Another example is that architects design a stereotype and mass produce to reduce the cost in construction and materials. It is inevitable unsuccessful because it takes more cost on the administration and organization. In this design “game”, architects still don’t win. So if architecture is not just a “shelter”, otherwise there is no need of architects as an independent profession, and architecture is not to solve the social problems, which here refers the slum, what is architecture and what is architect’s task. The answer is simple: architecture doesn’t solve social problem. It is more the representation of the human being’s power. As in , I just read recently: “We build for emotional and psychological purpose, as well for ideological and practical reason. The language of architecture is used to project power.”

Wednesday, April 11, 2007

slums_liwen

Slums
Liwen Zhang

Davis’ Planet of Slums presents highly astonishing figures. In a more recent edition of his work, he highlights that by 2050, “cities will account for all future world population growth” and that the number of residents in slums has reached a “staggering 78.2 percent of urbanities in the least-developed countries”. It has been long apparent that the issue of slums has reached what he deems as a global catastrophe upon which these slums serve not only as “warehouses for the poor”, but also as huge social and economical disasters.

The questions posed and debated by many scholars such as Janice Perlman, Shlomo Angel and Stan Benjamin collectively evaluate our perceptions, misunderstandings in the operations that uniquely happen in a slum environment and inappropriate ways upon which we have dealt with the problem up to date.

In Angel and Benjamin’s work, despite the seemingly pessimistic outlook on the many ways we have failed to resolve the problem of slums, we are presented with a very rational and logical point toward the end of the piece. They state that before any realistic solutions could materialize, there needs to be a “considerable change in attitudes and perceptions, the squatter problem simply can’t be solved”. This seemingly cynical outlook is perhaps a contrast to Perlman’s work, where her “myth of marginality” presents the mentality of those who inhabit the slums to be a positive one – where they are “highly optimistic and aspire to better education for their children and to improving the condition of their houses”. The myth in this case is a misconception on our part – in the parasitical ways we view them, hence limiting the opportunities for them to “fulfill their aspirations”.

What is interesting about Perlman’s work is the piece that she has most recently done titled the New Marginality. Notice that the title is in direct opposition to her previous assertions on the myth of marginality. In her new work, she went back and surveyed nearly all the same people that she did for her first research piece which resulted in the myth of marginality. In her second extensive research session, her findings were not so optimistic – hence the fact that marginality is no longer a myth. She notices that unlike in the 1960s, where slum inhabitants still had hope and saw their residences as transitional spaces, the 1990’s presents itself as an era of hopelessness. The same inhabitants that she surveyed back in the 60’s have now lost a lot of the previous aspirations and hopes they have had about leaving the slums. There is now sustained stigmatism in such areas, where slum inhabitants no longer feel comfortable and safe venturing into the formal streets of non slum areas. They explicitly state that based on what one wears, how one talks and one's lack of a permanent street address, these telling impressions then lead to many new forms of violence, thus sustained stigmatism and a new form of marginality.

I realize that up to this point I have generalized the many years of research and work of many renowned scholars; this is mainly attributed to the general purpose of this response piece and for clarity sake. I find Perlman’s work promising and extremely pertinent upon framing the course of action for what is to come. From her work, we realize another layer of added complexity to the already existing predicaments imposed. How do we then position ourselves as designers and planners for those subjected to this new form of marginality?

The Slum Solution: No Lists and Back to Week 6

Upon reading the six slum articles assigned, I was overwhelmed by the impulse to classify and define. Every text is replete with statistics, numbers and charts. If this is not enough, it is even evident in the titles: “Six Misconceptions about Squatter Settlements” by Janice Perleman and “Seventeen Reasons Why the Squatter Problem Can’t Be Solved” by Angel and Benjamin. It seems the popular solutions are all in outlined format, such as the Habitat Agenda in the UN-HABITAT’s State of the World’s Cities Report. Even Davis’ chapter The Prevalence of Slums, the author spends most of the text simply defining what a slum is. From these articles, one gets the sense that it is difficult just defining what a slum is and setting up committees to address them. Davis recognizes that this is due in large part to the disconnect between the committees and the slum inhabitants, citing that the governments that are positioned in between do not always want to divulge the numbers on which the committees depend. Nevertheless, it seems that the overwhelming urge to classify is a typical top-down, western approach that may not be very effective, especially when you consider how the world’s population in slums is growing.

With this established method, I am not surprised that one article was entitled “Thirty Years of the Urban Agenda: What Has Been Achieved?” Maybe it is the method itself that needs to be challenged. In Angel and Benjamin’s reason number five the squatter problem cannot be solved, entitled “completeness,” I thought of a word from weeks past—emergence. The article states, “communities take shape over time,” a bottom-up quality essential to emergence. However, the top down nature of committees, conferences and resolutions is prone to articles entitled “Seventeen reasons why the squatter problem can’t be solved.” Instead, maybe if slums are not addressed as a “problem” to be classified, but instead a set of design parameters, less lists and less slums would exist.

slum

Slum/Bin Wang

These articles inspire my consideration for the one third population on this planet, squatters, most of whom live in developing countries. Although there are also many squatters in the States, things are totally different. Based on my experience living in China and America, I feel most homeless people in America don’t intent to get a job. Many of them live in cities. Living in slums seems more a life style. While in China, most slum people have jobs (not good for sure) and are trying to get better ones for moving into cities.

My hometown, Suzhou, has one of the most well preserved city walls of the world. Attached to the outside wall, there used to be a lot of slums. As a child, I liked to go through these intimate neighborhoods. The fabric of the slums is still beautiful to me. After developing for decades, the slum had well organization and emerged into the typical housing style. However, when I went back from university last year, most slums (actually old houses) had been tore down, leaving the lonely city wall behind and several “nail residents” among the ruins. It was cruel to all the residence. I’ve be wondering where they are right now. Must be somewhere in the city. The ironical thing is that the position where they lived, from where they wanted to move into the city, had already become the centre of the city. The concept of “city” changed dramatically in the last 20 years. So they probably moved not into the “city” but to the edges of the “new city”.

The reason why most slums in China appear at the edge of cities is interesting. In China, we have policy for “registered permanent residence” according to which people can only live in their “permanent residence city”. For example a citizen born in Shanghai can’t work in Beijing under equal benefits unless changing the “registered permanent residence” to Beijing. That why people be restricted immigrating even in their own country makes no sense to me at all. But this is a policy. As a result, those people coming from the suburb have huge difficulties to get a “right identity” so it is hard to find a good job in the city. On reverse, without a job means no identity and no normal housing. The consequence is that more and more people gathered on the edge of the city waiting for an opportunity to move into the city. The slum areas thus become an in-between of suburb and cities. They witness the process of urbanism.

“Housing is a verb.” But the economic and political power have pushed this verb way beyond an architectural issue, or it never was.

Thursday, April 5, 2007

Archimera

Researching the etymology of “hybrid,” it was not surprising that the word came from the Latin root hybridia, meaning “offspring of a tame sow and wild boar.” It was also no shock that the word was considered rare before 1850. Checking Wikipedia.com, my suspicion was confirmed: Gregor Mendel published his groundbreaking paper “Experiments on Plant Hybridization” in 1866. Where I was surprised by etymology.com was that hybridia is believed by etymologists to have originated from the Greek word hubris. The most notable hybrid from Greek mythology—the chimera (goat / lion / snake)—signaled storms, shipwrecks and natural disasters.
The FOA’s chapter on the Yokohama Port Terminal entitled “the competition phase: in the eye of the twister” begins with the sentence “this is a project we never intended to win.” The UN Studio begins their article by talking about the “Manimal,” a Photoshop morphing of man / lion / snake (an incorrect and perhaps intentional description, as we discovered in class today). These perhaps unintentional allusions to the mythological qualities and meanings of hybrid are much more fascinating to me than the ultimate definition provided by these three readings: a search for new form. For FOA, they were interested in creating a hybrid “between a shed—a more or less undetermined container—and a ground,” with circulation paths being the mutating factor. The UN Studio took a similar approach to the same competition, stating, “this interweaving of various structuring principles – the gardens, infrastructure and construction – makes up the organization of the project.” According to these terms, hybridity in architecture lies primarily in formal, surface-oriented tactics.
Greg Lynn’s article “Animating Form” makes it clear that any forward-thinking architect must consider the above approach to architecture. Focusing on nascent digital technologies to accomplish quickly latent hybrid potentials, Lynn uses metaphors to make “the computer” familiar while simultaneously designing intentionally unfamiliar architecture. Comparing the computer to a pet, Lynn states, “just as a pet introduces an element of wildness to our domestic habits that must be controlled and disciplined, the computer brings both a degree of discipline and unanticipated behavior to the design process.” However, many of Lynn’s buildings to me have been missed opportunities. It seems that how the form is generated is consummate—the architecture being consequence of the process rather than impetus. I want to see the chimera, an architecture that does signal or react to the storm—the architecture that is truly animate

HYBRID

Van Berkel and Lynn's articles presented two specific sets of hybridization that had resonance to me: virtual and real, & animated and static. Virtualization has played a large part in my design education; whether it's due to specific professors pushing a certain method, or my own tendencies towards these technologies, I find that it plays an integral role in my design process. In fact so much so that as I design, I can no longer fully understand spaces in plan or section - that I actually rely heavily on a virtual 3 dimensional representation of my scheme to further develop ideas. The idea of hybridizing virtual and real is probably as old as civilization. As soon as the first cave drawings appeared the concept of representation was created. Historically architects have been masters of virtualization - conveying real space though 'virtual' media of plan and section, a projection or flattening of real space on two dimensional medium. But this hybridization between virtual and real becomes more and more intense as virtual technologies approach reality. With current 3D software the ability to convey a space realistically sometimes exceeds our mental capacities to distinguish virtual from real. The weakness in virtualization however, as Lynn points out, is that traditionally it has only been used for "rendering and imaging" rather than a "tool for design".

Virtualization becomes a much more powerful tool if used actively to modify or create new spatial realities, rather than being a passive/receptive mechanism to convey existing realities. This leads to the ability to "animate form", as Lynn saids, not as a literal movement of a discrete object, but a dynamic shaping of such by taking into account the forces that act upon the object. Many of Lynn's examples of digital techniques are instantly recognizable as ones found (but not exclusively) in the Maya software - his reference to 'inverse kinematics', 'keyframing', 'dynamics', 'deformers', 'expressions'. In my years here at Berkeley my studiomates and I alike have questioned the usage of Maya as the 3D component in design. The frequent argument was why use Maya when the rest of the industry was using either FormZ or 3dsMAX? The reason only became apparent as I began to touch upon ideas like linked nodes, shading networks - foreshadowing the realization that the program's nature was parametric. Parametrization essentially allows the existence of a feedback loop in which virtualization can actively and dynamically modify the output, or eventual reality of the design. It has taken a while, but parametric software in the field of architecture has finally come about recently. And embedded in that shift in ideology is the realization hybridization and parametrization creates opportunity for different systems (ie circulatory, structural, and programmatic - in FOA's port terminal) to interact and react to each other for a more compelling architecture.

sha_hybrid

[a little rambly]

Reading Lynn's Animate Form was actually truly exciting -- the example of the boat hull as not being dynamic but still responding to a variety of situations that occur over time was to me one of the best explanations of how to achieve or study dynamic architecture. It reminds me of the evolution of video and computer games. Before, movements were discrete -- walk forward, stop, then turn, then walk forward again. In the past few years, though, technology has come forward to view movement as a series of intensities in a continuum (ie walking is not a separate state but an increase in movement in the legs, etc..) so that hybrid movement can be achieved through blending. If characters walk and turn at the same time, pulling out weapons or things, the result is that each action affects the other. The final, visual effect, is of fluid movement, where turning affects the walk but then reduces intensity as the turn is finished. The upcoming game, Spore, is actually then an exercise in the procedural blending of monsters the user creates to interpret how it will walk and move.

In a field like gaming, though, animation and motion can still have literal expressions. Is what Lynn argues for a still frame of the blended movement of a character that is walking, jumping, and calling out to someone at the same time? If it is as simple as that -- that architecture is a moment captured from a series of flows and forces that change and grow over time, that would be fantastic.

Hybrid as brought up with the Manimal, too, generates some interesting thoughts, especially on blending of disciplines. I'm excited by the idea of hybrid practice, something that has been happening in other scales of design but seems to be a quieter subject in the world of architecture. This has been a continued source of confusion for me -- though there are a few firms like TODA and maybe AMO that seem to be intent on exploring the gap between architecture and design, within the design fields there is already a sense of a larger community. One DesignObserver article argues that graphic design does not deal with history, while architects remain embedded in it, but I don't think that's the answer. The discussion consistently returns to the idea of graphic design as an ephemeral product vs. architecture as a static, permanent being. That, then, makes me interested in graphic design that starts to cope with its own 'mortality' -- did the Cranbrook kids of the 90s come the closest to existential graphic design? When does architecture experience a similar crisis of self?

http://www.designobserver.com/archives/020666.html

hybrid

I have found that during my time here at Berkeley that much criticism and discussion in studio has been centered around the idea of transition and continuity of space and surface. In particular, I remember instance where one of my studio mates was criticized for not considering how two structural systems that he had developed did not transition from one to another; in other words his reviewers were recommending that the two systems blend or hybridize. Later in conversation with him he said that he didn’t see or understand why they would need to. Ever since that critique I found myself asking the same question. Why is continuity of space so important to this time in contemporary architecture?

I found these readings to be instrumental in answering these questions because they have put into perspective why hybrid is so important in contemporary architecture. It seems that paradigms in the world outside of architecture are changing along with technologies and therefore architecture as well is transitioning. People’s lives today incorporate many complex and changing factors due to cultural and technological shifts, and it seems that traditional senses of space are not suited to accommodate such situations. This is why the idea of flexibility integral to hybrid is so important. In FOA’s description of the Yokuhama terminal they write “Intensive space; that is, a kind of spatiality where the capacity of space is not directly related to size, and where the quality of space varies differentially, rather than as a discontinuity. Intensive space is generally more effective at dealing with shifting programmatic conditions, evolution of programs, etc…intensive space is differentially flexible, which means that if offers multiple conditions in a continuum” (pg. 17)

The article Animate Form also speaks of this flexibility when it talks about the boat hull as an example. It can function in many different temporal conditions because its form it carries smart points that can handle variable situations. “In this way, topology allows for not just the incorporation of a single moment but rather a multiplicity of vectors and therefore, a multiplicity of times, in a single continuous surface” (pg. 10). This idea of a smart continuous surface is essential to the conversation of our evolving cities where the lack of space will require architecture can that carry numerous functions and applications.

Animation/Hybrid

Jungmi Won


Motion and animation were confusing concepts to me. But, it was clarify with the first sentence, ‘motion implies movement and action, animation implies the evolution of a form and its shaping forces’.(P9) Keyword was forces.

‘Animate form’ is the article makes me think about why design languages are transformed from modern time to current. Main reason was the change of view toward architectural space. Majority of issues has risen between stasis and stability. Like author said, “Given a constant mass, stability is achieved through orbits rather than stasis. In the case of a single, simple gravity, stasis is the ordering system through the unchanging constant force of a ground point. In the case of a more complex concept of gravity, mutual attraction generates motion; stability is the ordering of motion into rhythmic phase.” (P14) From the moment when people wanted to express force, flow and all its motion in design, from the point where people thought architecture as a move from the diagram not an archive, animation process became necessary and complexity was started.

Complexity is always present as potential in even the most simple or primitive of forms. Moreover, it is measured by the degree of both continuity and difference that are copresent at any moment. (P31) The potentials are a reason we cannot abandon a difficult concept, time with force when animating form.

If hybrid is the concept as an intense fusion by a force and accumulated time, it can be related with this notion of ‘complexity’ in animating process. Then, can we think that hybrid is a result of animating? To me, it seems we cannot. In animating form, a logic of differentiation, exchange, and assemblage within an environment of gradient influences can be examined. It involves both time and force impact as its initial component. However, hybrid is a stasis when it lost its history. ‘The amalgamation generates a now notion of identity. The different features of the work are blurred and exist in layer which do not necessarily relate to each other or to the scale and structure of the shapes and substances form which they originate.( Move: P80)’

Hybrid – One response in a continuum.

“Because of its dedication to permanence, architecture is one of the last modes of thought based on the inert.” (Lynn, 11)

A consistent theme in the hybrid readings was the existence of a multiplicity of instances along a continuum and the advantages that using a computer in design brings in exploring this way of thinking.

FOA discussed intensive space, a differential space. “A continuous and homogenous space has been traditionally the instrument for flexibility, but intensive space is differentially flexible, which means that it offers multiple conditions in a continuum…”(FOA, 17) Is diversity flexibility?

Greg Lynn discusses non-Cartesian, vector and parameter based forms and describes them as animate. Animation, not to be confused with motion, is an evolution of form based on forces. Our ways of dusing technology itself is an animate form because it can be described in terms fo forces and parameters.
“If there is a single concept that must be engaged due to the proliferation of topological shapes and computer-aided tools, it is that in their structures as abstract machines, these technologies area animate.” (Lynn, 41)

At on point, Lynn discusses the Zoologist Thompson. “Thompson was one of the first scientists to notate gradient forces through deformation, inflection, and curvature. These three terms all involve the registration of force on form.” (26) In an odd coincidence, yesterday in my CE130 class, we derived formulas for deformation, inflection and curvature, each a derivative or integration of the other, derived from the forces, which integrate to find the shear, which integrate to find the moment, again to deflection, again to inflection and then curvature. The differential relationship between these materials to forces and inputs can be applied to a topological architecture. “[T]opology allows for not just the incorporation of a single moment but rather a multiplicity of vectors, and therefore, a multiplicity of times in a single continuous surface.” (Lynn, 13)

Lynn gives a caution though that we would do well to heed. “The challenge for contemporary architectural theory and design is to try to understand the appearance of these tools in a more sophisticated way that as simply a new set of shapes.” (Lynn, 17)

FOA, too, discussed the presense and power of meaninglessness in their design. “What is most interesting about the development of the competition is precisely how factual and “meaningless” the sequence of decisions that led the project was, despite the many associations that have been made between the project and certain philosophical, cultural or formal trends. In fact, we now see that meaninglessness as the order that builds multiple cultural resonances.” (FOA, 9) The meaningless resonates with an international style ideal. A superficiality and neutrality becomes a sort of international code. If a building is so abstracted it flirts with universal appeal.

In the hybrid article, (which begins with a hybrid phrase, ‘Architectural constructions’) this neutrality is addressed in the idea of scale. “Hybrid structures have no authentic recognizable scale, their organization is geared towards allowing function-related expansion and shrinkage and this results in overlaps and non-determinate spaces that flow into each other.” (Hybrid, 80)

Lynn argues that “multiplicity can constitute a cohesive identity.” (84) The one and the many is an age old problem, and one that is opened for exploration by modern computing methods. The challenge is to find multiplicity, neutrality and meaning at once. “Pragmatism is being bred to utopia in the hope that a painless merger between the two can be brought about.” (114) No small order, indeed, but if, as Lynn argues, technology is an animate form, our investigative tools will evolve with our questions, our architecture and ourselves.

Hybrid/Animation

Hybrid/Animation

Anders Rotstein

Un studio/van Berkel describes hybridization as “An intense fusion of construction, materials, circulation and programme spaces creates uncertainty as to the exact properties of the components from which these structures are assembled; they are hybrids which don’t know their history”(p79). Further on in the reading it is suggested that the hybrid structures have no authenticity and is created from function related expansion and shrinkage put of flows instead of programme spaces. The Manimal, a hybrid between lion and man, is the icon of the hybridization. The relationship between author and technique, relation to time and the relation of component part to whole are of high importance. The process of hybridisation is also described as a mutation over time.

Gregg Lynn describes animation as the evolution of form. It is very similar to hybridization but it is still ongoing, possibly never-ending. I especially liked a part in the “animate form” reading on page 19-20 where Lynn suggest how architects should see the cad-software to get rid of their “ethic of stasis”: “instead of approaching the computer as either a brain or nature, the computer might be considered as a pet. Like a pet, the computer has already been domesticated and pedigreed, yet it does not behave with human intelligence” and “one can cultivate an intuition into the behaviour of computer-aided design systems and the mathematics behind them.” I find the “animate form” reading as a great pedagogic work. It clarifies some of my misunderstandings from last years 101 with Anthony Bourke. Lynn puts the problem of stasis in focus and force upon the need for architecture of the early 21st century to find ways to incorporate time and force. It would have helped me a lot I would have read these readings in the beginning of last semester.

Wednesday, April 4, 2007

Hybrid_liwen

Reading response_ Hybrid
Liwen Zhang

The ideals shown through the notion of hybridization in architecture is a provocative one which calls for what Ben van Berkel would deem as “not a building design [but rather] a design of the relations between structure, circulation systems, programmatic spaces and surfaces”.

For van Berkel, the architecture of hybridization “amounts to the organization of continuous difference… free to assume different identities, architecture become endless”. The notion of ahistorical and acultural architecture, is not a novel thought, international style from the beginning of our last century is perhaps a direct response to the increasingly globalized paradigm of our time. However, as architecture starts to take on new systems of meaning, culture is redefined. Previously confined to racial, geographical and technical limitations, architecture, with the aid of innovative computer techniques for formal generation, material fabrication and structural and program organization, now embraces the increasing demands of a networked culture where the need for hybridization is imperative. Whether this hybridization calls for an integration of architectural systems, social and cultural livelihoods or the ephemeral, the role played by the use of computer aided design is a crucial one which continues to push the boundaries of contemporary architectural discourse.

Despite the fantastical properties that the computer brings to architecture, one which van Berkel aptly describes as a “computer-generated fantasy …being transformed into reality”, the use of such innovative computer techniques, is however heavily cautioned by Greg Lynn. Being the pioneer for the adoption of computer-based animation techniques, the use of animations to aid in representation for his architecture has become Lynn’s trademark. He poses that "the challenge for contemporary architectural theory and design is to try to understand the appearance of these tools in a more sophisticated way than as simply a new set of shapes”. For Lynn, the computer serves merely as a “pet” that has “already been domesticated”. Perhaps this need to disparage the computer serves as a way to alleviate the stigma that he previously mentions to be present in many architects, due to the fear of losing control as the ultimate designer to the cusps of generative and organizational software.

To fully integrate the use of innovative computer techniques is proving to be difficult as software programs demand high levels of expertise and control, thus one cannot blame Lynn’s cautions as many of us tend to be easily seduced by the provocative forms that new software allows for. The Yokohama Port Terminal project by Foreign Office Architects is a good example where the use of computers plays an integral and highly successful part of the realization of the project, with the architects retaining their roles at the forefront of the entire design process. This is probably attributed to the fact that the actual software used for solving structural needs for the project is not currently at the forefront of what is available out there, thus enabling such mediums to be more fully within our control. However, this hardly becomes an issue as the end product is truly what Alejandro Zaera-Polo describes it to be, “an organization that hybridizes a pure enclosure with topography”.

hybrid and animation

Hybrid and Animation/Bin Wang

Hybridization is about process. Animation is also about process. The difference between the two is that hybrid presents a certain status during the process of combination and inheritance while animation displays the transformation in a certain span of time. Hybrid can be a single object, but animation is more about continuity. No matter what was mixed in Manimal or works of Kielsler, when finished, they became physical hybrid. Hybrid is production of different forces, just as architecture.

Architecture, whatever the form looks like, is hybrid of different forces. Architects are always dealing with different forces, site, function, circulation, all the elements one can think about in design are forces. Ideas and conceptions come from forces. However, forces are changing. “All buildings are the mothers of ruins”. For architects, it is easy to know that architecture is about time, motion, or whatever, but it is difficult if not impossible to design something spans from constructions to ruins. In Animate Form, the author mentioned that “Instead of a neutral abstract space for design, the context for design becomes an active abstract space that directs form within a current of forces that can be stored as information in the shape of the form”. Building, under this circumstance, displays the inflection of forces, however, it is difficult for me to understand this as a process. When a building has been built, it lost the fluid and transmutability.

Process has a speed. Some processes can be caught in one second, such as the running or flying of animals, others might be detected in one million years, such as the formation of mountains. Architecture also has a speed of transformation. Actually, all buildings are changing, but the speeds of these processes are hard to aware.

The self-contradiction of Animate Form is that form is not a right tool to describe animation. In other words, the animate form which can be seen has a different speed than that of architecture.
So if architecture has a right way to express process and changing forces remains a question.